KezNews.com
DownloadsOther NewsForumBlogsWallpapersJokewareSearch

News letter:


Enter Your E-mail:

Dear Microsoft: Please get UAC right this time


section: microsoft, for your questions: KezNews forum, 30.5.2008

UAC could certainly have been handled better. It does something the security industry has been well aware of for a long time — it creates the “cry wolf” problem of popup fatigue (people turn off or ignore the popups after awhile).




Vista is more secure than XP, despite what others might say, but it still gets infected. Since over 80% of all infections are based on social engineering, the popups should focus on that weak point. If UAC targeted the key areas where people run into trouble (as opposed to harassing the user on inane actions), it would be far more helpful and potentially make a really significant impact on infection rates.

Absolutely right. A single request for permission doesn’t bother most people. What gets under the skin is the second UAC prompt, and the third, and the fourth, and so on. The closer together those dialog boxes arrive, the more annoying the phenomenon.

I was all prepared to lay out my modest proposal for how Microsoft should tweak UAC in Windows 7. And then I said, “Hey, wait a minute! I already did this.”

And sure enough, with a little help from Google I was able to reread “How Microsoft can save User Account Control.” which I wrote way back in May 2006, while Vista was still in beta. In that post, I offered four “suggestions that might ease the pain” of UAC. Two years later, I think those recommendations are still valid, so I’m reprinting them here, with a little updated commentary on each one:

Create a special Admin Mode. Power users would appreciate a UAC option that lets an administrator respond to a single prompt and temporarily open a session that runs with full administrative permissions. The devil is in the details, of course. How do you keep people from choosing this option as the default?

source: blogs.zdnet.com

send email Send link 2 friend  |  Permalink
<< previouse article
CodeLite IDE v1.0RC01
next article >>
Watch the Full Windows 7 Video Presentation, Not Just the Official Version

MORE RELATED ARTICLES:
Disabling UAC Slows Vista's Bootup Time? || Microsoft Exec: UAC Designed To Annoy Users || Has Windows Vista's UAC feature failed Microsoft? || Windows 7 Makes It on Microsoft.com for the First Time || Fixing Windows Vista: Taming UAC

Comments(4)

Wrong wrong and wrong

By John on 31.05.2008 - 13:05
"create a special admin mode."

the whole purpose of uac is to scrap the admin mode. when an 'admin' logs on then any rootkit that may be hiding dormant may get the opportunity to install itself without user intervention.

UAC is useless

By Amirz on 31.05.2008 - 15:05
uac is useless and annoying. i know its purpose for security reason in vista, but if we have good antivirus and tweak, again, it's useless. i always turn it off.

Help me related to SAN (storage area network)

By wasim on 01.06.2008 - 04:06
i an persuing the san but i have no enough material ralated to this can you plz provide me the topics

UAC implementation is correct

By gnugeek on 01.06.2008 - 11:06
i think uac can be little tweaked for less pop ups. the whole idea behind uac is also to force developers to write programs which dont need administrative priviledges like that of xp.


No new comments are allowed for this article.

For your questions use our KezNews Forum