KezNews.com
DownloadsOther NewsForumBlogsWallpapersJokewareSearch

News letter:


Enter Your E-mail:

VISTA vs. XP


section: windows, for your questions: KezNews forum, 7.1.2007

Want to know the differences between Vista and it's biggest competitor, Windows XP? An online article in the US has some basic information, but we thought it needed a bit more detail. So here's a much better rundown on the differences to expect!




SECURITY FEATURES

XP: In the original Windows XP, and with the first service pack or SP1, both versions still in use today, Windows XP has a built-in firewall that gave relatively good protection against hackers breaking into your computer.

The 2nd service pack, or SP2, improved the firewall to protect you from people trying to get it, and bad programs trying to get access out to the Internet, but it is still considered relatively basic compared with commercial offerings. Anyone serious about security should replace it with a good third party firewall or Internet security suite.

VISTA: Vista has a similar but improved firewall to Windows XP SP2, but anyone who is serious about their security will still replace it with a third party firewall or Internet security suite. Internet Explorer 7 has an ‘anti-phishing’ filter, but is known to slow down your surfing experience a little as sites you visit are checked by Microsoft’s servers for phishing attack dangers.

However IE7 and Firefox 2.0 have both been rated as only having partial success in detecting phishing sites, and as such have both earned a rating of ‘pretty terrible’ for anti-phishing prowess by us at ITWire.

A new ‘user account control’ system tries to protect you from yourself, so you don’t accidentally make changes to important system settings without being warned first. However pressing the ‘ok’ button lets you do whatever you want anyway, and experienced users will just be annoyed. What did I do? I turned it off completely and am not bothered by it anymore. You’ll probably do the same, too.

HOME ENTERTAINMENT

XP: Windows XP has always been able to play mp3 and video files, CDs, DVDs (with third party software), streaming media files and other forms of digital media with relative ease over the years.

VISTA: Finally, the Media Center capabilities comes built-into most versions of Windows Vista aside from the basic, entry level version. It has also been enhanced over the previous version, although reviewers claim it has not received as much of an improvement as the rest of Windows has over previous versions.

Vista also plays most other forms of digital media through it’s own Windows Media Player software, with a whole host of competing media players available to download, many free of charge, from the Internet.

GRAPHICAL USER INTERFACE

XP: Ridiculed as being the ‘Fischer Price’ version of the Windows 2000 interface, Windows XP was still a fresh update upon its release 5 years ago. Today, however, will still perfectly functional, it is starting to look a little long in the tooth, with Apple’s Mac OS X offering Vista like graphics for several years already.

VISTA: Very cool looking 3D icons, transparent ‘glass’ windows and other lovely eye candy such as the ‘Flip 3D’ way of flipping through open windows. This new graphics system is called ‘Aero’. However this will require a graphics card with enough grunt.

Older laptops may not be able to support the full Aero graphics experience, and will default to a mode which looks similar but lacks most of the eye candy effects, such as the transparent windows and Flip 3D effect.

A system wide desktop search engine is built-into Vista and is fully activated. Interestingly XP has a similar function but it was never explained properly, with most people very familiar with XP’s annoyingly slow search capabilities. Vista’s built-in search is fast, like Google’s Desktop Search, and is great to have already built-in.

PARENTAL CONTROLS

XP: Without third party software, the parental controls in Windows XP were rather limited and really didn’t prevent children from visiting inappropriate sites on the Internet.

VISTA: Excellent parental controls are built-into Vista, mirroring the powerful features that today’s third party software offers to parents today. Parents have control over the sites their children visit, and are able to see every site they visit or tried to visit.

NETWORKING

XP: Unless you know what you’re doing, Microsoft’s ‘set up Wizard’ for wired and wireless networks could seemingly never be counted on to actually work, leading to many frustrations for people simply trying to network two or more computers together.

VISTA: A great deal of concerted effort has gone into making Vista the easiest operating system to network with others, especially other Vista systems, so that anyone, even without massive computing experience, can easily set up a wired or wireless network.

For Australians, the Vista launch starts quite literally in a few hours, with proceedings starting at 9.30am on Thursday the 30th of November. We’ll be bringing you updates from the launch, along with any surprises they unveil or that we uncover.

source: VISTA vs. XP – a brief yet more detailed look

send email Send link 2 friend  |  Permalink
<< previouse article
2007 Office System Document: User Interface Evaluation Design Guidelines
next article >>
Office 2007 activation

MORE RELATED ARTICLES:
Vista SP1 RC Leaves XP SP2 in the Dust, but What About XP SP3? || Microsoft Makes Its Own Vista SP1 vs. XP SP2, Leaves XP SP3 Out || Windows XP Service Pack 3 - Will it turn XP into Vista? || Microsoft Hands out XP SP3 beta – Final SP for XP || XP SP3 Does Not Support Windows XP

Comments(12)

Windows XP vs. Windows Me 2007

By 101001010101010100011101 on 08.01.2007 - 03:01
i've been using vista for the past few months. i can't belive it took them over 5 years to do develop this crap of an os. without the "cute" gui, vista is just windows me 2007. m$ wants to rip people off again charging up to $399us, and $689us in europe for this shit! save your money and wait for m$ "vienna" in 2012. that is supposed to be a real "new" os, but if you leave it to m$, they'll screw that one up too, while ripping people off again.

Agree With 101001010101010100011101

By GTP on 08.01.2007 - 05:01
such a waste of 5-6 years, you think it would actually work when they got done with it. i was so upset, i switched back to xp! i completely agree, it should be named windows me 2007.

Vista has too much DRM

By p51d007 on 08.01.2007 - 05:01
i played around with it, and went back to xp. anyone who has good knowledge of computers can "secure" their computer without all the drm crap in vista. i'll pass until i'm forced to upgrade

vista...mirror of mac

By happycamper on 08.01.2007 - 11:01
maybe it took them 5 years to work out the photocopier...



Yep..tried it..too much hassle..back to XP for me

By Mark_Bear on 08.01.2007 - 11:01
after spending some two hours to totally screw the upgrade path i spent another 3 for a clean insatll. waste of time, nero wouldn't work with it, no sound among other things, all just too hard and no apparent benefits for me. i'm back to a "thankfully" ghosted backup of xp....good luck

Working fine!

By Danny on 08.01.2007 - 14:01
everything working fine here, except opengl with ati radeon x800xt, but that is to come.

i agree it's not worth the money at first glance, but i won't be switching back to xp. they're just about the same. nero works, sound works. no difference to running xp for me.

Vista fine with me

By MM on 08.01.2007 - 18:01
the version of windows vista is 6.0 and xp is 5.1 (2000 is 5.0). in a sense, vista is a totally new windows. just wait for the drivers to be compatible with vista.

vista Directx 10

By mETALFUZIOn on 08.01.2007 - 20:01
o vista so será mais usado quando todos os jogos começarem a sair em directx 10,porque aí não irá haver alternativa em usa-lo pk o xp nao ira suportar o dx10

------------------------------------------

just when all games will be in directx 10 then we will be forced to use the vista...

Vista DX10 WTF?

By 100101110001001000111010 on 08.01.2007 - 21:01
"o vista so será mais usado quando todos os jogos começarem a sair em directx 10,porque aí não irá haver alternativa em usa-lo pk o xp nao ira suportar o dx10"... i don'nt know wtf you are sayin' dude, but directx 10 without a video card that supports it is useless... next!

Vista clean install

By Radon on 08.01.2007 - 23:01
i did a clean install with vista ultimate x64 (msdn) on my pc.
quick specs: nvidia nforce4 motherboard, intel pentium extreme 965 3.73gh, nvidia 7800 gtx sli video card, 2gb ram, 1gb ethernet card.
while using the same computer specs, i did notice an overall increased performance. for example, when encoding movies... the no. of frames was 30-40% higher then it was previously in winxp. this was the most visible/shocking difference i saw right away.
internet speed tests are virtually identical, so no performance increases there.

the only driver problem i had was with the creative x-fi extrememusic sound card. that was fixed easy with their drivers, available to creative site.

i tried to install vista on a decent laptop (purchased last year) with an average video card, but the card would not take it.
the skin looked horrible, so yes, it would be useless to buy/upgrade to vista into average machines, since xp looks (and probably works, due to lack of processing power) a lot better.

overall, i'm very satisfied with the new version, since i do use a pc with decent processor power. aero skin just enjoys my video card, the effects are very apple'ish.
i give it a 10 for the cool looks/effects you get.
also the increased performance for my daily tasks makes me not to look back again to xp. if you are a web developer, php and mysql (both running on x64) will rock your world if you install the fastcgi module (iisfastcgi.dll).

please keep in mind that those are my own personal experiences, it does not mean that vista is better for everyone. it depends for what you use your os and how you use it.
one thing is sure, if you have a weak computer, forget about vista, for now. my laptop is back to windows xp.

I don' t like Vista

By Exillion on 18.01.2007 - 14:01
i've using vista for a period but i switched back to xp. vista is just crap, nothing else to say.



No Vista

By Anton on 20.01.2007 - 14:01
is good for nothig!!!!!!how is work?who knows!is comligate and useless



No new comments are allowed for this article.

For your questions use our KezNews Forum